In the mid-2000s, the PlayPump looked like one of the best ideas in development. A children's merry-go-round was connected to a water pump, so every turn lifted water into a storage tank. US donors put $16.4 million behind installing it across southern Africa.
Its backers counted pumps installed. Seen through the Impact Compass, the trouble shows up in three of the four dimensions.
- Environmental
- No major problem. The pump drew groundwater like any borehole.
- Economic
- Each PlayPump cost about $14,000, enough for several conventional hand pumps. Upkeep was meant to come from adverts on the water tanks, yet in Zambia in 2007, 75% of tanks carried none. In Mozambique, broken pumps stood idle for up to 17 months.
- Social
- Women in Mozambique said nobody asked them before the PlayPump arrived. Working hand pumps were taken out to make room, and villagers had no say over the pumps or the adverts on them.
- Individual
- The pump needed constant force to turn. When the children stopped playing, the work fell to women, who said it was much harder than the old hand pump, especially for older women.
PlayPumps International shut down in 2010, and many villages got their hand pumps back. Pumps installed is an output. The Impact Compass asks what changed for the people expected to use them, and that is where this idea broke.